FREE SHIPPING. EVERY ITEM. EVERY TIME.
A strawberry cheesecake sundae with cheesecake cubes and graham cracker crumbs, made with Hoosier Hill Farm Strawberry Ice Cream Mix
A stand-up pouch of Hoosier Hill Farm Real Dairy Ice Cream mix, strawberry flavored, with a pink swirl ice cream cone graphic on a white and red package against a light beige background.

Strawberry Ice Cream Mix

From $24.99
$24.99
$11.29lb
Shop

Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae

How to Make a Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae

All the flavor of strawberry cheesecake, none of the baking. This sundae layers creamy strawberry soft serve with soft cheesecake cubes, a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs, and a drizzle of strawberry syrup, sweet, fruity, and just a little bit fancy. It starts with Hoosier Hill Farm Strawberry Ice Cream Mix, a real dairy soft serve made with cream and milk, naturally flavored, and colored with red beet powder instead of artificial dye. Just add water and churn.

It comes together in about 10 minutes and tastes like a slice of cheesecake in a bowl, which makes it an easy showstopper for guests or a weeknight treat.

Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 0 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes (plus churning)
Yields About 4 sundaes

Ingredients

11.8 oz Hoosier Hill Farm Strawberry Ice Cream Mix (one batch)
21.2 oz cold water
1 cup cheesecake cubes
1/4 cup graham cracker crumbs
Strawberry syrup, for drizzling (optional)

Shop Strawberry Ice Cream Mix

Directions

  1. Blend. Whisk together the strawberry soft serve mix and cold water until smooth. Churn in an ice cream machine, or freeze and stir occasionally until creamy.
  2. Layer. Scoop the prepared strawberry soft serve into bowls and top with the cheesecake cubes.
  3. Top. Sprinkle with the graham cracker crumbs, then drizzle with optional strawberry syrup and serve.

Tips

  • Keep cheesecake cubes cold. Cut them straight from the fridge and add them just before serving so they hold their shape against the soft serve.
  • Make it a parfait. For the layered look in the photo, alternate soft serve, cheesecake, and graham crumbs in a tall glass instead of a bowl.
  • Fresh berries, too. Sliced fresh strawberries alongside the cheesecake cubes add color and a juicy bite.
  • Churn firm. Soft serve straight from the machine holds the toppings best. If it is too soft, freeze it for 20 minutes before scooping.
  • No machine? No problem. Whisk the base, then freeze and stir every 30 minutes until creamy, about 3 to 4 hours. A Ninja Creami works too.

How to make cheesecake cubes

You do not need to bake anything. Use a slice of store-bought New York style cheesecake or a no-bake cheesecake, and cut it into small cubes while it is well chilled so the edges stay clean. Keep them in the fridge until the moment you assemble, since cold cubes hold their shape best on the soft serve. In a pinch, cheesecake bites from the freezer section work too.

More ways to use the mix

Strawberry soft serve is a summer staple on its own. Blend a scoop with milk for a strawberry milkshake, the way we do in our old-fashioned vanilla milkshake, fold in fresh chopped strawberries during the last minutes of churning for a strawberry chunk style, or serve it in a waffle cone.
A stand-up pouch of Hoosier Hill Farm Real Dairy Ice Cream mix, strawberry flavored, with a pink swirl ice cream cone graphic on a white and red package against a light beige background.
A stand-up pouch of Hoosier Hill Farm Real Dairy Ice Cream mix, strawberry flavored, with a red and white design showing product information, mixing instructions, and a cupcake illustration on a light beige background.
Instructional graphic showing how to use an ice cream mixing machine. Large text reads 'HOW TO USE' above steps: adding water, whisking, and churning.
A promotional graphic with the text 'BIG FLAVOR, ZERO FUSS' above six circular badges reading GMO Free, Gluten Free, 0 Trans Fats, Additive Free, Artificial Free, and Nuts Free on a red and cream background.
A package of strawberry ice cream mix is shown next to a young girl pouring pink strawberry smoothie into a white blender container, with text callouts about simple storage, easy to use, and zero waste.
Promotional graphic for frozen desserts with the headline 'FROZEN FAVORITES MADE EASY' on a dark red background. The scene shows labeled examples of frozen treats: a pink swirl soft-serve cone, a pink milkshake in a glass with whipped topping, a slice of layered ice cream cake on a white plate, two ice cream sandwich bars on a dark plate, and two pink popsicles on a tray.
Instructional graphic for making a strawberry cheesecake sundae featuring a prepared dessert, a bag of Hoosier Hill Farm Real Dairy Ice Cream Mix, and ingredient callouts on a red and cream background.
Instructional graphic for making strawberry ice cream mix, with text reading 'REAL DAIRY, NO REFRIGERATION' and 'STRAWBERRY ICE CREAM MIX,' plus mixing and churning instructions and a photo of pink strawberry powder in a metal bowl.
A promotional graphic with a textured pink background and a cream rounded rectangle containing red text that reads 'LESS WASTE = MORE SAVINGS' and 'MORE THAN JUST CONVENIENCE,' followed by smaller text about Hoosier Hill Farm's shelf-stable products.
A red and cream informational graphic listing ingredients such as sugar, cream, milk protein isolate, nonfat dry milk, dextrose, natural flavors, red beet powder, tamarind seed gum, salt, xanthan gum, and guar gum. It includes a 'Contains: Milk' warning and a 'Store in a cool/dry place' icon, with the Hoosier Hill Farm logo at the bottom.
Nutrition facts panel for a protein powder product, showing a red left side with serving size and calories, and a black right side highlighting 8g protein, 14g fat, 230 calories, and 15% calcium.
A promotional graphic with a red and cream background featuring the text 'PREMIUM INGREDIENTS. EXCEPTIONAL QUALITY.
A white cardboard box with a large red front panel featuring the white Hoosier Hill Farm logo and text, plus red text on the side, shown on a plain light beige background.
A top-down view of a mound of fine light pink powder in a clear round container, set against a solid white background.
New

Featured Product

Strawberry Ice Cream Mix
$24.99
$24.99
$11.29lb
  • Real Dairy
  • No Fillers
  • Simple Prep
Size: 35.4 oz
View full details

We've Got Answers

More of our favorite recipes!

A jar of high protein peanut butter overnight oats made with Hoosier Hill Farm Peanut Butter Powder
Breakfast

High Protein Peanut Butter Overnight Oats

A strawberry cheesecake sundae with cheesecake cubes and graham cracker crumbs, made with Hoosier Hill Farm Strawberry Ice Cream Mix
Desserts

Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae

Chocolate ice cream tacos in waffle shells with strawberries and chocolate drizzle, made with Hoosier Hill Farm Chocolate Ice Cream Mix
Desserts

Chocolate Ice Cream Tacos